Compare category

Smart switches and dimmers comparisons

Wall switches and dimmers that play nicely with Home Assistant and local automation.

Read the buying guide → All smart switches and dimmers →

Standout picks

Strongest overall pick

Aqara Wireless Mini Switch

Owned and reviewed

Aqara · HA: excellent · local: excellent

single-button Zigbee controller supporting single, double and long press actions

Product notes →

Also strong on local control

Shelly Plus i4

Shelly · works offline: yes

Fully local via HTTP REST API or MQTT. No cloud account required. Inputs are processed locally and can trigger actions without internet.

Why it stands out →

Another easy starting point

SONOFF SNZB-01P

SONOFF · setup: easy

Home Assistant users who want a cheap physical button for automations

See buyer notes →

All smart switches and dimmers, side by side

Filter, sort, and open "More" on any row for what it's best at, setup, power, and cloud posture. Prices are the last verified read where there is one; the rest show a price band.

Showing 34 of 34 Ordered by Home Assistant fit, then local control. Click a column heading to re-sort.

Smart switches and dimmers compared: Home Assistant fit, offline behavior, protocols, hub requirement, price, and where to buy.
						Where to buy
Aqara Wireless Mini Switch Aqara Owned and reviewed More Best for triggering scenes or toggling lights with single, double and long press Standout Tiny single-button Zigbee controller with single, double and long press actions, fully local. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup easy Power battery	excellent	yes	Zigbee	yes	$15.90checked Sep 7	Amazon ↗ *
Shelly Plus i4 Shelly More Best for Home Assistant users who want to turn existing wall switches into multi-action scene controllers Standout Four switch inputs that detect single, double, triple and long presses - turns the switches you already have into scene controllers. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power hardwired	excellent	yes	Wi-Fi, MQTT, Bluetooth	no	budget	Amazon ↗ *
SONOFF SNZB-01P SONOFF More Best for Home Assistant users who want a cheap physical button for automations Standout The cheapest Zigbee button available, with single, double, and long press support for triggering automations. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup easy Power battery	excellent	yes	Zigbee	yes	$16.90checked Sep 11	Amazon ↗ *
Zooz ZEN30 Double Switch Zooz More Best for bathrooms or kitchens where a fan and light share one gang box Standout Dimmer plus on/off relay in one gang box. Control a light and fan independently without taking up two switch spots. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power hardwired	excellent	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$44.95checked Sep 23	Amazon ↗ *
Zooz ZEN32 Scene Controller Zooz More Best for power users who want a wall-mounted automation control panel in every room Standout Main relay button plus four scene buttons with LED indicators. A wall-mounted automation command center. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power hardwired	excellent	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$47.95checked Sep 9	Amazon ↗ *
Zooz ZEN34 Remote Switch Zooz More Best for adding a second switch point without running new wires Standout Battery-powered Z-Wave paddle remote that looks like a real switch. Mount anywhere without wiring. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power battery	excellent	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$37.95checked Sep 5	Amazon ↗ *
Zooz ZEN71 On/Off Switch Zooz More Best for lights or loads that should not be dimmed, like closets, garages, and fans Standout Simple, reliable Z-Wave on/off paddle switch with multi-tap scene support. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power hardwired	excellent	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$41.95checked Sep 5	Amazon ↗ *
Zooz ZEN72 800LR Dimmer Switch Zooz More Best for Z-Wave Home Assistant setups wanting a quality dimmer switch Standout Z-Wave 800 Long Range with multi-tap scene control - local, reliable, and interference-free. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power hardwired	excellent	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$44.95checked Sep 5	Amazon ↗ *
Zooz ZEN74 Toggle Dimmer Zooz More Best for homes with existing toggle switches where you want to keep the same look Standout Toggle-style Z-Wave dimmer that matches older homes without forcing a paddle switch aesthetic. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power hardwired	excellent	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$43.95checked Sep 5	Amazon ↗ *
Zooz ZEN76 800LR On/Off Switch Zooz More Best for loads that should not be dimmed, like exhaust fans, closet lights, and garbage disposals Standout Z-Wave 800 series on/off paddle switch with Long Range support and multi-tap scene control. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power hardwired	excellent	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$43.95checked Sep 5	Amazon ↗ *
Zooz ZEN77 800LR Dimmer Switch Zooz More Best for main living area dimmers in Z-Wave Home Assistant households Standout Zooz's flagship paddle dimmer with Z-Wave 800 series, smooth dimming, and multi-tap scene control. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power hardwired	excellent	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$46.95checked Sep 6	Amazon ↗ *
Inovelli Blue Series 2-1 Inovelli More Best for Home Assistant users building a serious Zigbee lighting system Standout Scene control and LED notifications make it unusually capable for serious Home Assistant and Zigbee setups. Local control excellent Cloud cloud-tinged (low) Setup moderate Power in-wall switch / dimmer	excellent	yes	Zigbee	yes	$19.99checked Sep 6	Amazon ↗ *
Philips Hue Tap Dial Switch Philips Hue More Best for bedside or living room wall mount where you want physical buttons and a dimmer dial without wiring Standout Physical rotary dial for dimming combined with 4 programmable scene buttons in a battery-powered remote. Local control excellent Cloud cloud-tinged (low) Setup easy Power battery	excellent	yes	Zigbee, Bluetooth	yes	$54.99checked Sep 9	Amazon ↗ *
Shelly Dimmer Gen4 Shelly More Best for Dimmer 2 owners who need a replacement or want the same hidden approach on another circuit Standout Hides in the wall box behind your existing switch like the Dimmer 2 did, and adds Zigbee 3.0 and Matter to the Wi-Fi and Bluetooth radios. Local control excellent Cloud cloud-tinged (low) Setup moderate Power hardwired	excellent	yes	Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Zigbee, Matter, MQTT	no	mid	Shelly ↗
Shelly Dimmer 2 Shelly Discontinued Owned and reviewed More Best for existing Shelly Dimmer 2 owners who already have one installed and working Standout Hides the smart bits behind an existing switch instead of forcing a visible full-switch replacement; discontinued by Shelly Group, with the Shelly Dimmer Gen4 as the current behind-the-switch replacement. Local control excellent Cloud cloud-tinged (low) Setup moderate Power in-wall retrofit dimmer module	excellent	yes	Wi-Fi, MQTT	no	mid	Shelly ↗
Aqara Light Switch H2 (US) Aqara More Best for US households building a Thread-based smart home with local control Standout Dual-radio in-wall light switch: it runs either Zigbee 3.0 or Matter over Thread, one at a time, and ships in Thread. 1/2/3-channel options for the US market. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power mains	good	yes	Matter, Thread, Zigbee	no	$47.49checked Sep 7	Amazon ↗ *
Eve Dimmer Switch Eve More Best for US/Canadian homes that want local-first dimming without cloud dependency Standout Privacy-first Thread in-wall dimmer switch with smooth local dimming via Matter. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power mains	good	yes	Matter, Thread	no	$54.95checked Sep 7	Amazon ↗ *
Eve Light Switch Eve More Best for households building a privacy-first Thread smart home (US/Canada and EU versions available) Standout Privacy-first Thread in-wall switch with Matter support and zero cloud dependency. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power mains	good	yes	Matter, Thread	no	$49.95checked Sep 8	Amazon ↗ *
GE Enbrighten Z-Wave Smart Dimmer Jasco More Best for Z-Wave Home Assistant setups wanting a proven, reliable dimmer Standout One of the most battle-tested Z-Wave dimmers - a staple of smart home builds for years. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power hardwired	good	yes	Z-Wave	yes	mid	Amazon ↗ *
IKEA BILRESA Dual Button IKEA Owned and reviewed More Best for Matter and Thread Home Assistant setups wanting a cheap scene or light controller Standout Cheap two-button controller that runs fully local over Matter-over-Thread. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup easy Power battery	good	yes	Matter, Thread	yes	$6.99checked Aug 28	IKEA ↗
Leviton Decora Smart Z-Wave Dimmer Leviton More Best for Z-Wave-based Home Assistant setups in US and Canadian homes Standout Commercial-grade Z-Wave dimmer with Decora paddle design, built to last with fully local control. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power wired	good	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$46.52checked Sep 8	Amazon ↗ *
Leviton Decora Smart Z-Wave Fan Controller Leviton More Best for automating ceiling fan speed based on temperature or time of day in Home Assistant Standout 4-speed Z-Wave ceiling fan controller in a standard Decora paddle form factor. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power wired	good	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$57.22checked Sep 1	Amazon ↗ *
Leviton Decora Smart Z-Wave Switch Leviton More Best for lights and loads that do not need dimming, like bathroom fans, closet lights, and outdoor lights Standout No-nonsense Z-Wave on/off switch with Leviton's commercial-grade reliability. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup moderate Power wired	good	yes	Z-Wave	yes	$49.87checked Sep 8	Amazon ↗ *
SONOFF MINI Extreme R4 (Matter) SONOFF More Best for tight switch boxes where other relays won't fit Standout One of the smallest Matter-compatible smart relays — fits where others can't. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup advanced Power hardwired	good	yes	Wi-Fi, Matter	no	$12.90checked Sep 6	Amazon ↗ *
ThirdReality Smart Button ThirdReality More Best for adding physical button controls to Home Assistant automations on the cheap Standout Three actions (single, double, hold) in a tiny, cheap Zigbee button. Local control excellent Cloud local-first (none) Setup easy Power battery	good	yes	Zigbee	yes	$19.99checked Sep 13	Amazon ↗ *
Philips Hue Wall Switch Module Philips Hue More Best for any room with Hue smart bulbs where guests or family members flip the wall switch and kill your automations Standout Keeps constant power to smart bulbs while converting your existing wall switch into a Zigbee scene controller. Local control excellent Cloud cloud-tinged (low) Setup moderate Power mains	good	yes	Zigbee	yes	mid	not listed
ELTAKO Impulse Switch ELTAKO More Best for European electricians and Home Assistant users adding Matter switching behind existing wall switches Standout Impulse switching relay with Matter over Wi-Fi in a flush-mount module, with a potential-free 16A contact. Local control good Cloud local-first (none) Setup advanced Power mains	good	yes	Matter, Wi-Fi	no	premium	ELTAKO ↗
ELTAKO Universal Dimming Actuator ELTAKO More Best for European Home Assistant users who want Matter dimming added behind an existing wall switch Standout Universal dimming actuator with Matter over Wi-Fi in a module compact enough for a flush-mounted back box. Local control good Cloud local-first (none) Setup advanced Power mains	good	yes	Matter, Wi-Fi	no	premium	ELTAKO ↗
Shelly BLU Button1 Shelly More Best for Home Assistant users who want cheap portable buttons for triggering scenes and automations Standout Pocket-sized Bluetooth button with multi-press detection - up to four distinct actions from one button. Local control good Cloud local-first (none) Setup easy Power battery	good	yes	Bluetooth	yes	budget	Amazon ↗ *
SwitchBot Bot SwitchBot More Best for retrofitting dumb devices you cannot or do not want to replace, like coffee makers or garage wall buttons Standout A mechanical arm that physically pushes buttons and flips switches, turning any dumb device into something you can automate. Local control good Cloud local-first (none) Setup easy Power battery	good	yes	Bluetooth	no	$25.99checked Sep 11	Amazon ↗ *
ThirdReality Matter Smart Switch (MT1) ThirdReality More Best for renters who can't replace wired switches Standout Battery-powered Matter-over-Thread switch that physically flips your existing dumb switch - zero wiring required. Local control good Cloud local-first (none) Setup easy Power battery	good	yes	Matter, Thread	yes	$34.99checked Sep 9	Amazon ↗ *
Lutron Caseta Diva Smart Dimmer Lutron More Best for buyers who want the safest mainstream smart dimmer recommendation Standout Exceptional wall-switch usability with a reputation for boring reliability, which is exactly what most homes need. Local control good Cloud cloud-tinged (low) Setup moderate Power in-wall dimmer switch	good	yes	Proprietary, Clear Connect	yes	$74.20checked Sep 8	Amazon ↗ *
Philips Hue Dimmer Switch Philips Hue More Best for adding physical controls for Hue lights in rooms where rewiring is not an option Standout Magnetic mount Zigbee remote with four buttons and long battery life. Local control good Cloud cloud-tinged (low) Setup easy Power battery-powered remote	good	yes	Zigbee	yes	$26.99checked Sep 9	Amazon ↗ *
TP-Link Kasa Smart Dimmer Switch KS220M TP-Link More Best for adding motion-activated dimming to a single-pole switch box Standout Motion-activated Wi-Fi dimmer from a major brand with a built-in PIR occupancy sensor. Local control good Cloud cloud-tinged (medium) Setup moderate Power hardwired	good	yes	Wi-Fi	no	mid	Amazon ↗ *