How I test
Last updated: November 13, 2026
Every page here starts from one question: does this device keep working from inside my house when the internet is gone? This page explains how I judge that, what I look at in Home Assistant, and how to tell a device I run from one I researched.
What I mean by local control
A device counts as local when three things hold. It keeps working with the internet unplugged. It talks to Home Assistant over a radio or protocol inside the house, such as Zigbee, Z-Wave, Thread, Matter or a local Wi-Fi API, rather than through a vendor's server. And once it is set up, it needs no vendor account to keep running.
Some devices need the maker's phone app for the first setup and nothing after. The Aqara FP2 is the usual example, and the presence sensor guide says so in its opening paragraph. Product pages rate every device with the same words, so two devices can be compared directly: local control runs from excellent to none, cloud dependency from none to high, and Home Assistant integration quality from excellent to poor.
What I look at in Home Assistant
First, which integration the device uses: a core Home Assistant integration, ESPHome, Zigbee through ZHA or Zigbee2MQTT, Matter, or a custom integration from the Marketplace. A custom integration depends on whoever maintains it, which is worth knowing before you buy.
Then what shows up once it is paired, and what is missing compared with the vendor's own app. A presence sensor that exposes occupancy but not its zones, or a plug that reports power but not energy, is a smaller product in Home Assistant than the box suggests. Product pages list these compatibility facts under "Local control facts", each with the page it came from, usually the Home Assistant integration documentation.
What breaks when the internet goes down
For each device I ask what still works with the internet link down: does it still switch, still report its state, and still run the automations that live in Home Assistant? The usual failures are cameras that only record to a vendor cloud, voice assistants that send audio away to be understood, and integrations that poll a vendor server instead of the device.
For a device I have not run, the answer comes from the documentation. Home Assistant labels every integration with how it talks to the device, such as Local Push, Local Polling or Cloud Polling, and the manufacturer's own pages say which features need an account.
Devices I run and devices I researched
Most products on this site are researched rather than run in my house, and About explains how that research is done. When I run a device, its product page carries my own review with a rating out of 5, and the reviews page lists every one. Inside a guide, each pick says which it is: either that I run it, or that I haven't run it and what the pick rests on instead, usually the spec sheet, the Home Assistant documentation and what other Home Assistant users report.
A review covers the units I have and the way I use them. My Philips Hue rating, for example, covers bulbs I have had for years, not the newest generation. If a page does not describe my experience with a device, treat it as research. The write-ups in My Smart Home show how some of the gear I run is wired together.
Corrections
If something here is wrong, tell me. An exact model number, firmware version or source link makes it quicker to check. Corrections to the site's own notes are listed with their sources on What changed.